Nice product overall.
I gave one less star as it doesn't suit what I was after exactly but overall this is a great product. I only use it as an eyeliner/shadow. A little too sparkly for what I wanted and I don't like how I have to use a powder over it for it to set - but this is expected from the type of product. It does hold well thought with the Aleph powder. The colour is good for lining the eyelid, not too bold or light. It is especially nice to be using a product that isn't full of nasty ingredients like I have been using for so long!